Saturday, June 21, 2008

Where You Are Is More Than What You Do

Lance Pritchett, a development ecnonomist that has worked at the World Bank and with a current position at Harvard, argues that the number one factor determining a person's income is where they are born. He takes the novel approach of looking at the average income by citizenship not by country. In this way, he seperates out how much location affects earnings. Quoting the conclusion, "...for those billion people departure from the country is one of the largest national industries in terms of its contribution to average material welfare per person." Limiting immigration dooms billions of people to inescapable poverty.


No one is going to be able to convince me that those children born in San Diego are inherently better than those children born in Tijuana, but an impenetrable border means that their lives will play out very differently. Now consider a child born in Iowa. There are large regions in the state that have experienced a steady population decline since the 1930s. What if all the people born in Iowa were forced to stay there? Someone born in Iowa is free to go to San Diego even though they were born a thousand miles farther away than the child born in Tijuana.

Friday, June 20, 2008

Solving The Entitlement Problem

The Current Dilemma

Currently we spend over half of the total federal budget on entitlement programs. The three major programs in order of liability to the US taxpayer are: medicare, medicaid and social security. I don't think that I have to elaborate to much on this only to say that we too many people retiring and not enough new workers entering the workforce. When these programs started in reaction to the Great Depression, the worker to retiree ratio was around 30 to 1. Today that ratio is about half of that. Part of the reason for this is because people are living longer. In the 1930s, the life expectancy for a white American male was around 65. You paid into the system your whole life and when you retired, you were given some security to live out the twilight of your life. Today, 65 is the new 55. Health care options are more plentiful and more expensive. Because today's social security payments get paid to those receiving the benefits today, most predictions estimate that these programs will become insolvent before the end of the first half of this century.


A Possible Solution

Many people have floated policy ideas including raising the minimum age to receive benefits and removing the cap on the income that gets taxed for social security. I have another proposal: liberalize our current immigration policies. The fact is we need more workers. The representative immigrant that currently wants to enter the country legally is resourceful and ambitious. They may either be looking for a better way to support their children or are wanting to start a family. It is true that in many cases they are low-skilled, but in terms of returns on investment, it is easier to import children than to "grow" them here. They enter the workforce quicker and supplement our many entitlement programs with their wages.

Thursday, June 19, 2008

Children are the Future

The next time you hear how much undocumented individuals are costing US taxpayers, I would invite you to consider where that cost comes from. The great majority of the estimated cost comes from undocumented immigrants raising children. Many of the children are United States citizens. What good can come from deporting the parents only to leave the children behind? Studies show that deportation doesn't solve the "drain" at the local, state, and federal levels*. I haven't seen any estimates on either side of this issue that would disagree with this fact.

How much your kids are costing the US taxpayer? Your kids go to school and enjoy a world-class education; they enjoy safe communities, clean water, sanitary living conditions and have access to basic healthcare. That is all very expensive. Sometimes as parents we may wonder if our children will ever be a productive member of society, but that day always comes. We can have that same hope for the children of the undocumented. Studies have estimated that the present discounted value of the fiscal impact of a child in an undocumented family is somewhere around 80,000 dollars*. That means that after they grow up, they get better jobs than their parents and pay back into a system that gave them a good education and a stable society in which to thrive.


*Studies to be inserted later. Available upon request.