Saturday, June 21, 2008

Where You Are Is More Than What You Do

Lance Pritchett, a development ecnonomist that has worked at the World Bank and with a current position at Harvard, argues that the number one factor determining a person's income is where they are born. He takes the novel approach of looking at the average income by citizenship not by country. In this way, he seperates out how much location affects earnings. Quoting the conclusion, "...for those billion people departure from the country is one of the largest national industries in terms of its contribution to average material welfare per person." Limiting immigration dooms billions of people to inescapable poverty.


No one is going to be able to convince me that those children born in San Diego are inherently better than those children born in Tijuana, but an impenetrable border means that their lives will play out very differently. Now consider a child born in Iowa. There are large regions in the state that have experienced a steady population decline since the 1930s. What if all the people born in Iowa were forced to stay there? Someone born in Iowa is free to go to San Diego even though they were born a thousand miles farther away than the child born in Tijuana.

Friday, June 20, 2008

Solving The Entitlement Problem

The Current Dilemma

Currently we spend over half of the total federal budget on entitlement programs. The three major programs in order of liability to the US taxpayer are: medicare, medicaid and social security. I don't think that I have to elaborate to much on this only to say that we too many people retiring and not enough new workers entering the workforce. When these programs started in reaction to the Great Depression, the worker to retiree ratio was around 30 to 1. Today that ratio is about half of that. Part of the reason for this is because people are living longer. In the 1930s, the life expectancy for a white American male was around 65. You paid into the system your whole life and when you retired, you were given some security to live out the twilight of your life. Today, 65 is the new 55. Health care options are more plentiful and more expensive. Because today's social security payments get paid to those receiving the benefits today, most predictions estimate that these programs will become insolvent before the end of the first half of this century.


A Possible Solution

Many people have floated policy ideas including raising the minimum age to receive benefits and removing the cap on the income that gets taxed for social security. I have another proposal: liberalize our current immigration policies. The fact is we need more workers. The representative immigrant that currently wants to enter the country legally is resourceful and ambitious. They may either be looking for a better way to support their children or are wanting to start a family. It is true that in many cases they are low-skilled, but in terms of returns on investment, it is easier to import children than to "grow" them here. They enter the workforce quicker and supplement our many entitlement programs with their wages.

Thursday, June 19, 2008

Children are the Future

The next time you hear how much undocumented individuals are costing US taxpayers, I would invite you to consider where that cost comes from. The great majority of the estimated cost comes from undocumented immigrants raising children. Many of the children are United States citizens. What good can come from deporting the parents only to leave the children behind? Studies show that deportation doesn't solve the "drain" at the local, state, and federal levels*. I haven't seen any estimates on either side of this issue that would disagree with this fact.

How much your kids are costing the US taxpayer? Your kids go to school and enjoy a world-class education; they enjoy safe communities, clean water, sanitary living conditions and have access to basic healthcare. That is all very expensive. Sometimes as parents we may wonder if our children will ever be a productive member of society, but that day always comes. We can have that same hope for the children of the undocumented. Studies have estimated that the present discounted value of the fiscal impact of a child in an undocumented family is somewhere around 80,000 dollars*. That means that after they grow up, they get better jobs than their parents and pay back into a system that gave them a good education and a stable society in which to thrive.


*Studies to be inserted later. Available upon request.

Thursday, May 1, 2008

A May Day Look at Civil Disobedience

Some people might take issue with the term "undocumented" as opposed to "illegal", but I purposely use the term to highlight the fact that there is a common mistake that many people make when discussing undocumented immigration. The term "illegal" denotes something sinister and criminal about the activity. There are many attempts to try to reframe the debate this way because when we build up a group of people as evildoers, it is easier to mete out all kinds of disproportionately harsh treatment against them. While people who cross the border without documentation are breaking the law, they aren't breaking any criminal laws. Let me explain: While I make no claims to be a legal expert, there are two classes of law: civil and criminal. Anti-immigrant groups often cite unrepresentative analogies to stir up anti-immigrant sentiment. They liken undocumented immigration to breaking into someone's house and stealing stuff. Last time I checked, no one owns the United States and there is clear theoretical and empirical evidence to suggest that both immigrants and native populations benefit from the added economic activity.

So the next time you feel like saying "illegal" I invite you to reconsider, unless you use the term consistently. I bet there are a lot of illegal drivers out there today speeding and improperly changing lanes.

Monday, April 28, 2008

Disabusing Folks of a Few Misconceptions

I got an email from a good friend of mine and part of it addressed immigration in a way that I think illustrates how facts and figures can be misrepresented. In responding to some of the points in that email, I hope to bring some clarity to the issue of the undocumented among us.

Conservatism On Its Head

Internationally, there are three factor movements that can be restricted, or liberalized, depending on a countries domestic policies: real goods, capital, and labor.

Conservatism has always stood for free trade, letting each person gain by their own best efforts through competition, in other words, small government. You only have to look at Bush's current efforts to get a free trade deal with Columbia or the typical pro-union, anti-free trade line that is hawked by Democrats every election year to realize that free trade is a conservative issue. Buying only American products sounds real good until you realize that you have to start paying triple for back-to-school stuff (read: clothes, shoes, school supplies).

I think we can also agree that free capital mobility is also a conservative bulwark. Do you want big government telling companies or individual investors how and where they can invest their money? Capital controls, the process by which the government prevents companies and individuals from investing in other areas of the world, is a slippery slope to total control. Some infamous countries with capital controls: China, Venezuela, and Cuba.

We see clear benefits from free trade and free capital mobility, but we still haven't been able to wrap our heads around the fact that free labor mobility is also a conservative issue. If free trade and free capital mobility are making us better off, than free labor mobility has been, and is, beneficial for all involved.


Deconstructing 14 Bogus (to Various Degrees) Arguments Against Free Labor Mobility


I want to start by listing a few facts:

First, illegal immigrants don't have access to federal welfare programs, period. This point is highlighted by the fact that all the literature cited to support these 14 arguments against free labor mobility all show that it is only legal immigrants and US citizens that are accessing these programs. Because the tag lines use the term "illegal", I have assume that either the original author is wantonly misrepresenting the facts, or more likely, they haven't taken the time to read the article that they are citing.

Second, the legal immigrants and US citizens that are accessing these welfare programs are almost all children (of undocumented immigrants). This is also made very plain by reading the cited literature. What the author of the original email fails to note is that there is a fundamental flaw with the methodology used in the papers cited. Think about it this way: let's take all your children and think about how much they take from the federal, state, and local governments. The largest costs for children of the undocumented are the same costs that lower income documented children access: medicaid and education. If the story stops there, then we could fairly say that children are a complete drain, not only on us as parents but also on society. Obviously, children grow up, get jobs, and become productive members of society.

In the book,
The New Americans : Economic, Demographic, and Fiscal Effects of Immigration, some of the leading experts in economics, demography, statistics, and other related fields got together to try to get a hand on this subject. They found that when you account for all the payments from the government and to the government from current children of undocumented you end up with a net positive payment to the government in the order of somewhere between 80,000 to 100,000 dollars over the lifetime of the individual, even when you account for the time value of money. By the time children are benefiting society, they are no longer a part of their parents' household, so the cited studies count the costs of investing in children without looking at the returns on investment.


1. $11 Billion to $22 billion is spent on welfare to illegal aliens
each year by state governments. Verify at: http://tinyurl.com/zob77

Point 1 is misleading for all the reasons previously states. Additionally, there have been studies done by the Congressional Research Services (1) that clearly state that undocumented immigrants don't have access to welfare programs. It also notes that the percentage of non-citizens that are at or below the poverty level is falling even as the total population is growing.

2. $2.2 Billion dollars a year is spent on food assistance programs
such as food stamps, WIC, and free school lunches for illegal aliens.
Verify at: http://www.cis..org/articles/2004/fiscalexec.html

3. $2.5 Billion dollars a year is spent on Medicaid for illegal
aliens.
Verify at: http://www.cis..org/articles/2004/fiscalexec.html

Points 2 and 3 are from the same study.

First, a note on the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS): This is a variant of a "chicken little" message from the 70s. The CIS can be traced back to the zero population movement. They are now attacking immigration on the same grounds. If it was politically viable, they would be right there with the Chinese trying to tell us how many children to have. Second, go to the CIS link and you will discover that under the heading "Summary Methodology", they rely heavily on the study that was later turned into a book that I previously cited as being an argument for free labor mobility.

Quoting the report:

To estimate the impact of households headed by illegal aliens, we rely heavily on the National Research Council's (NRC) 1997 study, "The New Americans."

This is another clear case of taking the bits and pieces that they want to promote their implicit zero population growth argument. They either unknowingly or willfully ignore the fact that spending money on children of the undocumented is a good investment.

If this weren't enough it seems that the executive summary of this report concedes the point. Quoting the report again:
Many of the costs associated with illegals are due to their American-born children, who are awarded U.S. citizenship at birth. Thus, greater efforts at barring illegals from federal programs will not reduce costs because their citizen children can continue to access them.

4. $12 Billion dollars a year is spent on primary and secondary school
education for children here illegally and they cannot speak a word of
English! Verify at:
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0604/01/ldt.0.html

Children going to school?!! What will they do next? Go to college?

5. $17 Billion dollars a year is spent for education for the
American-born children of illegal aliens, known as anchor babies Verify
at http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0604/01/ldt.01.html

I am happy to concede this point.

6. $3 Million Dollars a DAY is spent to incarcerate illegal aliens.
Verify at: http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0604/01/ldt.01.html

7. 30% percent of all Federal Prison inmates are illegal aliens.
Verify
at: http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0604/01/ldt.01.html

Points 7 and 8 both address incarceration costs. I included a link at the bottom that debunks these claims (2). I think that the general idea the author is trying to convey is that undocumented immigration and free labor mobility opens us up to the "criminal" element. Some of the talking points from the linked document below are:

  • Federal prison only makes up 8% of all inmates. So talking about 30% of 8% is about 2.5% of the total prison population in America.
  • Undocumented adult male immigrants are 5 times less likely to commit a crime than adult male natives
  • Undocumented adult male high school dropouts are 10 times less likely to commit a crime than an native male high school dropout
  • Undocumented immigration from 1994 to 2005 doubled. Violent crime fell 34% during the same time period. Property crime fell by 26.4%.
  • The conservative think tank, Americas Majority Foundation, found that crime rates are lowest in states with the highest immigration growth rates.
    • From 1999 to 2006, the total crime rate declined 13.6 percent in the 19 highest-immigration states, compared to a 7.1 percent decline in the other 32 states.
    • In 2006, the 10 “high influx” states—those with the most dramatic, recent increases in immigration—had the lowest rates of violent crime and total crime.
8. $90 Billion Dollars a year is spent on illegal aliens for Welfare &
social services by the American taxpayers. Verify at:
http://premium.cnn.com/TRANSCIPTS/0610/29/ldt.01.html

To review: These are children of undocumented. Those children get jobs and start paying into the system.

9. $200 Billion Dollars a year in suppressed American wages are caused by
the illegal aliens. Verify at:
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0604/01/ldt.01.html

Immigrants don't take jobs, they make them.
The overwhelming majority of economists agree that immigrants increase the
economic productivity and thus the wages of natives.
  • A 2006 study by University of California, Davis, economist Giovanni Peri found that because immigrant workers generally “complement”—rather than substitute for—native workers in terms of their education and skills, immigration tends to increase the productivity, and therefore the wages, of natives.
  • As a result of this “complementarity,” the White House Council of Economic Advisers concluded in a 2007 report that roughly 90 percent of native-born workers experience wage gains from immigration, which total between $30 billion and $80 billion per year.The overwhelming majority of economists agree that immigrants increase the economic productivity and thus the wages of natives.
10. The illegal aliens in the United States have a crime rate that's two
and a half times that of white non-illegal aliens. In particular, their
children, are going to make a huge additional crime problem in the US .
Verify at: http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0606/12/ldt.01.html

Point 10 is a blatant misrepresentation of documented facts.



11. During the year of 2005 there were 4 to 10 MILLION illegal aliens
that crossed our Southern Border also, as many as 19,500 illegal aliens from
Terrorist Countries. Millions of pounds of drugs, cocaine, meth, heroin
and marijuana, crossed into the U. S from the Southern border Verify at:
Homeland Security Report: http://tinyurl.com/t9sht

This smacks of fear mongering. We definitely need to figure out what to do about the drug problem, but have been waging the war on drugs since the 80s so this is nothing new. Last time I checked, I've never heard of a Mexican terrorist. Have you? The best antidote against extremism is economic opportunity!

12. The National Policy Institute, "estimated that the total cost of mass
deportation would be between $206 and $230 billion or an average cost of
between $41 and $46 billion annually over a five year period." Verify
at: http://www.nationalpolicyinstitute.org/pdf/deportation.pdf

This seems to be making the argument for me. Mass deportation seems like Big Brother and government waste in its worst form.

13. In 2006 illegal aliens sent home $45 BILLION in remittances back to
their countries of origin. Verify at:
http://www.rense.com/general75/niht.htm


It is their money. They can do whatever they want with it. The economy is not zero sum. If I pay my taxes, who cares what I do with the rest of the money. Read my post of tax compliance for more information on this issue.

14. "The Dark Side of Illegal Immigration: Nearly One Million Sex Crimes Committed by Illegal Immigrants In The United States." Verify at:http://www.drdsk.com/articleshtml

I have to admit that I was taken aback by this last one. Dr.
Deborah Schurman-Kauflin, an expert in serial killer profiling, seems to be a little out of her element. She found that 2% of all incarcerated immigrants were child molesters. She then make the HEROIC leap that that must mean that 2% of all undocumented immigrants are child molesters. This is the worst kind of misrepresentation not just because it is so false but also because it seeks to wrongfully demonize a whole group of people.

If I told you that 30% percent of all criminals were murderers, how would you calculate the total number of murderers? You would probably want to know how many criminals there are. For adult undocumented males, the incarceration rate is .7%. Dr. Schurman-Kauflin assumes that 100% of undocumented males have been incarcerated. Wow.

The total cost is a whopping $ 338.3 BILLION DOLLARS A YEAR.

This cost represents an investment in children who live in the United States legally. I don't like the fact that they broke the law but kicking out the parents will only make things more expensive. Do you want Big Brother raising these kids?


(1)(http://assets.opencrs.com/rpts/RL33809_20070119.pdf)
(2)(http://www.immigrationpolicy.org/images/File/factcheck/ImmigrantsandCrime03-08.pdf)

Sunday, March 9, 2008

Missourian Gubernatorial Candidate Seeks Scapegoat

Controversy in Missouri

In a story I picked up on a Google news alert, State Treasurer Sarah Steelman, a Republican running for the governorship in Missouri, seems to be running on a hard-line immigration stance. I chose Steelman's policy analysis as my first review because it allows me to highlight and debunk some major myths about immigration in the United States.

According to the author, Steelman is presenting some findings, in her official capacity as State Treasurer, before the a State Senate committee based on her interpretation of a 2005 report put out by the Pew Hispanic Center. Jeffery S. Passel, a Senior Research Associate for the Pew Hispanic Center and highly-respected expert in the field of immigration reported on the numbers and characteristics on undocumented immigrants based on the March 2005 CPS census information. In that report, he reports that there is somewhere in the range of 35,000 to 65,000 undocumented individuals in Missouri. That number is down from between 55,000 and 85,000 from the same report of the previous year.

Based on the 2005 report and the reported average nationwide wage of 25,000 for undocumented individuals, Steelman produces a cost of "between 26 and 49 million ever year" to Missouri taxpayers. She is quoted further to say that "total revenue lost to the state and federal government combined is between $243,613,125 and $449,499,375."

Where does she come up with these numbers? Her methodology of multiplying the average wage by the amount of workers gives you a gross aggregate wage bill between 875 million and 1.6 billion. If you consider a 30% tax rate, you end up with Steelman's combined cost estimate of foregone tax revenue, assuming that undocumented don't currently pay taxes and assuming that there true tax bill is 30%. As a married graduate student with one small child, my adjusted gross income was close to the average wage for an undocumented individual and I paid 0% federal and state taxes. If you throw another child into the picture you are at the federal poverty line.

Estimating the Actual Tax Liability for the Average Undocumented Worker

Assuming that the undocumented worker is single the Federal tax bill on 25,000 dollars of taxable income is 3,363 which works out to be about 13.5%. If that individual happened to be married that Federal tax bill falls to 2,971 or a tax rate of about 12%. This is somewhat more complicated because two people working generated. Assuming that all single individuals are working, I estimate based on Passel's numbers that 77% of married men are working and 41% of married women work. (I include a link to Passel's report below but feel free to email me on how I got these numbers.) Based on these measures, we now have two people working at a set average wage with a certain probability. The average wage for a married couple would be:

.77(25,000) + .41(25,000) = 29,500.

The federal tax bill for this amount is 4,038, in other words, a tax bill of 13.7%.

I am keeping things simple by assuming that they wouldn't qualify for any tax credits, etc. A conservative estimate also allows me to avoid nitpicking about different tax scenarios.

In addition to federal taxes, any individual pays an additional 7.65% (6.2% OASDI and 1.45% Medicare). Since 52% of undocumented workers are married, we can calculate the average total federal tax rate to be:

.52(21.25%) + .48(21.15%) = 21.2%

I went through the Missouri state tax return form and ignored any possible standard deductions and calculated a 1,275 tax bill for 25,000 in taxable income. That is a tax rate of 5.1%. Humor me for a second and let's assume that not one undocumented individual pays a red cent in taxes. At a tax rate of 26.3%, we are now talking about a tax bill in the range 230,125,000 and 427,375,000. It seems that even with a very conservative estimate, Steelman's 30% tax rate seems a little high.

Her estimate may include sales tax, but I am not sure how Steelman would explain how undocumented individuals are able to avoid sales tax.

After all calculation, I have tried to establish what a documented worker would have to pay, but a documented worker has access to social security, medicare, and other means-tested programs that undocumented workers cannot legally access. Steelman's accusation of undocumented immigrants "cheating" Missouri tax payers only applies if the following two conditions are true:

1) undocumented immigrants don't pay taxes

and

2) undocumented immigrants get access to means-tested programs

I intend to show that these two statements are not generally true.

Are Undocumented Immigrants Ripping off the System?

In a report issued by the American Immigration Lawyers Association , they cite several studies that debunk the notion that their is widespread welfare fraud among undocumented populations. Some major points of the report:

  • Undocumented immigrants are never eligible to receive welfare assistance
  • Less than 1% of all households headed by undocumented immigrants receive cash assistance compared to 5% of native households

Do undocumented immigrants pay taxes?

Even though undocumented immigrants cannot qualify for public welfare assistance, they are still paying into the system. In a December 2007 Congressional Budget Office Report titled, The Impact of Unauthorized Immigrants on the Budgets of State and Local Government, notes that "researchers from the Urban Institute, the Migration Policy Institute, the Pew Hispanic Center, and the Center for Immigration Studies have assumed a 55 percent compliance rate for income, Social Security, and Medicare taxes." Further noted is the study conducted by the University of California at San Diego that found that in 2006, 75% of undocumented workers had had taxes withheld from their paychecks. In other words, over half of the individuals are paying into the system without having any legal right to the services that they are supporting.

This phenomenon shows up in audits by the IRS. All anomaly returns get funneled into an "earnings suspense file" (ESF) which collects all the returns have invalid social security information. For TY 2004, there were 7.9 million invalid W-2s. Over 50% percent where concentrated in four states: California, Texas, Florida, and Illinois. The total wage amount for these W-2s was 53 billion dollars. Based on those earnings, undocumented workers paid 4.2 billion dollars into Medicare and Social Security, not including federal and state taxes.

Final Analysis

Based on the March CPS census records, undocumented immigration fell in Missouri by 20,000 from 2004 to 2005. If 55% of the undocumented are paying the proper taxes then the State of Missouri is receiving somewhere between 437,500 and 812,500 in state income tax from a population that receives little in return.


original story: http://www.stltoday.com/blogzone/political-fix/political-fix/2008/03/steelman-declares-illegal-immigrants-cost-state-at-least-26-million-a-year/

missouri tax form http://dor.mo.gov/tax/personal/individual/forms/2007/m1040af.pdf

Passel report://pewhispanic.org/files/reports/61.pdf

Committee on Ways and Means report: http://bulk.resource.org/gpo.gov/hearings/109h/30637.txt

CBO report http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/87xx/doc8711/12-6-Immigration.pdf