In a story I picked up on a Google news alert, State Treasurer Sarah Steelman, a Republican running for the governorship in Missouri, seems to be running on a hard-line immigration stance. I chose Steelman's policy analysis as my first review because it allows me to highlight and debunk some major myths about immigration in the United States.
According to the author, Steelman is presenting some findings, in her official capacity as State Treasurer, before the a State Senate committee based on her interpretation of a 2005 report put out by the Pew Hispanic Center. Jeffery S. Passel, a Senior Research Associate for the Pew Hispanic Center and highly-respected expert in the field of immigration reported on the numbers and characteristics on undocumented immigrants based on the March 2005 CPS census information. In that report, he reports that there is somewhere in the range of 35,000 to 65,000 undocumented individuals in Missouri. That number is down from between 55,000 and 85,000 from the same report of the previous year.
Based on the 2005 report and the reported average nationwide wage of 25,000 for undocumented individuals, Steelman produces a cost of "between 26 and 49 million ever year" to Missouri taxpayers. She is quoted further to say that "total revenue lost to the state and federal government combined is between $243,613,125 and $449,499,375."
Where does she come up with these numbers? Her methodology of multiplying the average wage by the amount of workers gives you a gross aggregate wage bill between 875 million and 1.6 billion. If you consider a 30% tax rate, you end up with Steelman's combined cost estimate of foregone tax revenue, assuming that undocumented don't currently pay taxes and assuming that there true tax bill is 30%. As a married graduate student with one small child, my adjusted gross income was close to the average wage for an undocumented individual and I paid 0% federal and state taxes. If you throw another child into the picture you are at the federal poverty line.
Estimating the Actual Tax Liability for the Average Undocumented Worker
Assuming that the undocumented worker is single the Federal tax bill on 25,000 dollars of taxable income is 3,363 which works out to be about 13.5%. If that individual happened to be married that Federal tax bill falls to 2,971 or a tax rate of about 12%. This is somewhat more complicated because two people working generated. Assuming that all single individuals are working, I estimate based on Passel's numbers that 77% of married men are working and 41% of married women work. (I include a link to Passel's report below but feel free to email me on how I got these numbers.) Based on these measures, we now have two people working at a set average wage with a certain probability. The average wage for a married couple would be:
.77(25,000) + .41(25,000) = 29,500.
The federal tax bill for this amount is 4,038, in other words, a tax bill of 13.7%.
I am keeping things simple by assuming that they wouldn't qualify for any tax credits, etc. A conservative estimate also allows me to avoid nitpicking about different tax scenarios.
In addition to federal taxes, any individual pays an additional 7.65% (6.2% OASDI and 1.45% Medicare). Since 52% of undocumented workers are married, we can calculate the average total federal tax rate to be:
.52(21.25%) + .48(21.15%) = 21.2%
I went through the Missouri state tax return form and ignored any possible standard deductions and calculated a 1,275 tax bill for 25,000 in taxable income. That is a tax rate of 5.1%. Humor me for a second and let's assume that not one undocumented individual pays a red cent in taxes. At a tax rate of 26.3%, we are now talking about a tax bill in the range 230,125,000 and 427,375,000. It seems that even with a very conservative estimate, Steelman's 30% tax rate seems a little high.
Her estimate may include sales tax, but I am not sure how Steelman would explain how undocumented individuals are able to avoid sales tax.
After all calculation, I have tried to establish what a documented worker would have to pay, but a documented worker has access to social security, medicare, and other means-tested programs that undocumented workers cannot legally access. Steelman's accusation of undocumented immigrants "cheating" Missouri tax payers only applies if the following two conditions are true:
1) undocumented immigrants don't pay taxes
and
2) undocumented immigrants get access to means-tested programs
I intend to show that these two statements are not generally true.
Are Undocumented Immigrants Ripping off the System?
In a report issued by the American Immigration Lawyers Association , they cite several studies that debunk the notion that their is widespread welfare fraud among undocumented populations. Some major points of the report:
- Undocumented immigrants are never eligible to receive welfare assistance
- Less than 1% of all households headed by undocumented immigrants receive cash assistance compared to 5% of native households
Do undocumented immigrants pay taxes?
Even though undocumented immigrants cannot qualify for public welfare assistance, they are still paying into the system. In a December 2007 Congressional Budget Office Report titled, The Impact of Unauthorized Immigrants on the Budgets of State and Local Government, notes that "researchers from the Urban Institute, the Migration Policy Institute, the Pew Hispanic Center, and the Center for Immigration Studies have assumed a 55 percent compliance rate for income, Social Security, and Medicare taxes." Further noted is the study conducted by the University of California at San Diego that found that in 2006, 75% of undocumented workers had had taxes withheld from their paychecks. In other words, over half of the individuals are paying into the system without having any legal right to the services that they are supporting.
This phenomenon shows up in audits by the IRS. All anomaly returns get funneled into an "earnings suspense file" (ESF) which collects all the returns have invalid social security information. For TY 2004, there were 7.9 million invalid W-2s. Over 50% percent where concentrated in four states: California, Texas, Florida, and Illinois. The total wage amount for these W-2s was 53 billion dollars. Based on those earnings, undocumented workers paid 4.2 billion dollars into Medicare and Social Security, not including federal and state taxes.
Final Analysis
Based on the March CPS census records, undocumented immigration fell in Missouri by 20,000 from 2004 to 2005. If 55% of the undocumented are paying the proper taxes then the State of Missouri is receiving somewhere between 437,500 and 812,500 in state income tax from a population that receives little in return.
original story: http://www.stltoday.com/blogzone/political-fix/political-fix/2008/03/steelman-declares-illegal-immigrants-cost-state-at-least-26-million-a-year/
missouri tax form http://dor.mo.gov/tax/personal/individual/forms/2007/m1040af.pdf
Passel report://pewhispanic.org/files/reports/61.pdf
Committee on Ways and Means report: http://bulk.resource.org/gpo.gov/hearings/109h/30637.txt
CBO report http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/87xx/doc8711/12-6-Immigration.pdf

No comments:
Post a Comment