Thursday, May 1, 2008

A May Day Look at Civil Disobedience

Some people might take issue with the term "undocumented" as opposed to "illegal", but I purposely use the term to highlight the fact that there is a common mistake that many people make when discussing undocumented immigration. The term "illegal" denotes something sinister and criminal about the activity. There are many attempts to try to reframe the debate this way because when we build up a group of people as evildoers, it is easier to mete out all kinds of disproportionately harsh treatment against them. While people who cross the border without documentation are breaking the law, they aren't breaking any criminal laws. Let me explain: While I make no claims to be a legal expert, there are two classes of law: civil and criminal. Anti-immigrant groups often cite unrepresentative analogies to stir up anti-immigrant sentiment. They liken undocumented immigration to breaking into someone's house and stealing stuff. Last time I checked, no one owns the United States and there is clear theoretical and empirical evidence to suggest that both immigrants and native populations benefit from the added economic activity.

So the next time you feel like saying "illegal" I invite you to reconsider, unless you use the term consistently. I bet there are a lot of illegal drivers out there today speeding and improperly changing lanes.

No comments: